The 20 Best Restaurants in Pinetop-Lakeside

Baked In Pinetop is a cozy neighborhood bakery known for its fresh sourdough loaves, specialty breads, and an array of pastries, from danishes to almond croissants. Baked goods are prepared with attention to texture and flavor, drawing a steady stream of regulars. Friendly, upbeat staff contribute to a lively atmosphere, and popular items often sell out as the day goes on.

Johnny & Dee's Picnic Basket offers classic American breakfast favorites in a clean, comfortable diner-style setting. Guests highlight fluffy pancakes, hearty omelets, customizable oatmeal, and generously poured coffee and juice. Service is attentive and efficient, even during busy mornings, creating a welcoming start to the day.

Red Devil Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria serves classic Italian comfort dishes alongside hand-tossed pizzas with a crisp, generously topped crust. Guests highlight hearty pastas such as lasagna and chicken piccata, complemented by warm bread, seafood starters, and traditional desserts. Attentive, efficient service and a casual, welcoming dining room create an easygoing neighborhood atmosphere.

Mr. Zeke's Restaurant offers a broad American menu featuring hearty burgers, sandwiches, pasta, and more for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Guests highlight the flavorful specialty burgers, prime rib and pastrami sandwiches, and dishes like Inferno Pasta. Attentive, helpful service and an outdoor patio with heat lamps contribute to a comfortable dining experience.

Chalet Restaurant & Lounge combines a chalet-style exterior with a nautical-inspired interior, creating a distinctive setting for classic American and seafood dishes. Guests note well-prepared specialties such as lamb, fish and chips, and creamy chicken entrées, along with tempting desserts. Attentive, well-trained staff and a lively dining room and bar make it a long-standing gathering place for the local community.

Los Corrales Mexican Restaurant serves classic Mexican comfort food, from sizzling fajitas and enchiladas to flautas, chimichangas, and burritos, all known for generous portions and vibrant flavor. Fresh chips with flavorful salsa begin the meal, and warm tortillas accompany many plates. The dining room features colorful Mexican decor that creates a home-style cocina feel, while the attentive, friendly staff contribute to an inviting experience.

Johnnie D's Pizza & His Co. serves classic Italian-American fare, with New York–style pizzas, hearty pasta plates, and traditional dishes like veal parmigiana. Portions are described as generous and flavorful, making it a popular choice for satisfying, comfort-style meals. The casual, family-friendly setting and generally attentive service create an easygoing dining experience.

The Lodge Sports Bar & Grill offers a classic bar setting with pool tables, a long bar, and outdoor tables. The menu focuses on hearty pub-style fare, with sizable burgers, tacos, and fries frequently praised for their flavor and generous portions. Guests highlight the well-made cocktails and welcoming, attentive bartenders that contribute to an easygoing, social atmosphere.

The Lions Den combines classic dive-bar character with an expansive patio featuring a concert stage, multilevel seating, and weekend live music and trivia. The menu centers on hearty bar favorites such as burgers and a noted prime rib French dip sandwich. Service is generally attentive, supporting a lively, casual atmosphere with a subtle country feel.

Charlie Clark's Steakhouse is a long-standing local favorite known for hearty American steakhouse classics and generous portions. Guests enjoy steaks, ribs, burgers, and roasted chicken, often paired with traditional sides like baked potatoes and salads. A lively bar area filled with locals and cozy booths by the windows create an inviting atmosphere, while the attentive staff keeps service smooth even when the restaurant is busy.

Pinetop Brewing Company pairs house-brewed beers with hearty pub favorites in a casual, welcoming setting. Guests praise the variety and quality of the beers, including flights and Belgian-style options, alongside generously portioned burgers, pizzas, and shareable snacks. Crispy tenders, loaded nachos, and flavorful sides are frequently highlighted. Attentive, friendly service rounds out the laid-back brewpub experience.

The Hungry Buffalo offers hearty American fare in a bustling, welcoming setting. Guests highlight the well-cooked ribeye steaks and rotating specialty pizzas, featured on Thursday nights, for their flavor and generous portions. Attentive service from both staff and owners, along with a varied drink and wine selection, contributes to the lively, social atmosphere, sometimes enhanced by live music on the patio.

W & Z Asian Bistro & Sushi Bar offers a broad Asian menu with a strong focus on fresh sushi, pleasantly surprising many visitors with its quality. An extensive selection provides options for both sushi enthusiasts and those preferring cooked dishes. Service is described as professional, attentive, and efficient, contributing to an easygoing, comfortable dining experience.

Grumpy Jakes BBQ is a country-style diner known for its slow-smoked meats, including tender brisket and ribs served with a tangy, sweet barbecue sauce. Classic sides such as beans, potato salad, and cornbread muffins complement the hearty plates, along with house-made pies for dessert. The old-time décor and 1950s music create a nostalgic, laid-back setting, supported by attentive, welcoming service.

Johnnie Ds Pizza offers hearty East Coast–style pies with generous slices and a focus on classic, comforting flavors. In addition to pizza, the menu includes Italian-American favorites such as pasta dishes and substantial meatball sandwiches. The setting is simple and unpretentious, with consistently pleasant, attentive service and the convenience of delivery.

Pasta House Co offers classic Italian cooking in a converted house along White Mountain Boulevard in Pinetop-Lakeside. Guests describe a warm welcome and intimate rooms, some overlooking the boulevard. The kitchen prepares traditional dishes and can accommodate certain special requests, such as osso buco. An appealing selection of wines by the glass complements the meal.