The Best Pizza Restaurants in Costa Mesa

Al's New York Cafe is a compact, no-frills spot known for its New York–style pizzas with thin, foldable slices and generous toppings. Guests also find a selection of pastas, sandwiches, and white pizzas, with daily specials adding variety. The interior is simple and clean, with a few indoor and outdoor tables, and service is generally quick and courteous, making it convenient for dine-in or takeout.

Pitfire Pizza serves wood-fired pies with a thin, crisp crust and a flavorful char. Guests highlight both classic toppings and creative seasonal combinations, such as roasted pumpkin with goat cheese and greens. The space offers an urban, laid-back feel, complemented by attentive, friendly service. Delivery orders arrive with the same well-made crust and satisfying balance of cheese and toppings.

Gina's Pizza and Pastaria offers classic Italian-American comfort food with an emphasis on flavorful pizzas, including a well-regarded gluten-free option. Guests praise the thin crusts, rich sauces, and sides such as tender meatballs and crisp salads. The restaurant features a pleasant, nicely decorated dining room and efficient, welcoming service, and is popular for both dine-in and takeout.

Set in a converted mid-century gas station, 2145 EATS offers inventive pizzas and a focused selection of small plates in a distinctive corner location. Diners highlight the thin, bubbly-crusted pies, including a blue cheese and honey combination, along with dishes like grilled octopus and Brussels sprouts. A spacious back patio and friendly, attentive service create a relaxed neighborhood hideaway.