The Best Pizza Restaurants in Petaluma

Lunchette

4.32(0 reviews)

USD 15

Pizza / 25 4th St, Petaluma, CA 94952-3003, United States /

Fresh, Locally Sourced Lunch Fare

Lunchette is a small downtown Petaluma spot specializing in fresh, ready-made salads, soups, and focaccia-style pizza by the slice. The menu highlights seasonal ingredients sourced from local, environmentally conscious producers. Guests can take meals to go or enjoy them at the outdoor picnic table. Reusable containers and clear recycling and composting options reflect the restaurant’s focus on sustainability.

Hector's Pizza

3.87(0 reviews)

USD 15

Pizza / 1420 S McDowell Blvd, Petaluma, CA 94954-5400, United States /

Cozy Neighborhood Pizzeria

Hector’s Pizza is a small, casual spot known for generously sized pizzas with scratch-made dough and plentiful toppings. The menu also features comforting Italian-style dishes such as pasta, salads, and hearty sandwiches. Guests note the clean dining area and prompt, attentive staff, creating a welcoming setting for a relaxed meal.

Old Chicago

3.67(0 reviews)

Pizza / 41 Petaluma Blvd N, Petaluma, CA 94952-3001, United States /

Historic Chicago-Style Pizzeria

Old Chicago is a long-standing Petaluma landmark known for its hearty Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas. Set on the second floor of a vintage brick building, it offers a cheerful dining room with a sense of local history. Pizzas are baked to a rich, substantial finish and arrive piping hot. Attentive, welcoming service completes the classic pizzeria experience.

Pinky's Pizza Parlor

3.55(0 reviews)

USD 25

Pizza / 321 Petaluma Blvd S, Petaluma, CA 94952, United States /

Longstanding Neighborhood Pizzeria

Pinky's Pizza Parlor is a longtime local favorite known for its classic pizzas made with fresh ingredients and flavorful toppings. Guests enjoy a relaxed, family-friendly dining room with big-screen sports and a welcoming community feel. Popular choices include hearty specialty pies, housemade sausage, and garlic bread, paired with a cold beer for a casual meal.

The New Yorker Pizza

3.00(0 reviews)

USD 15

Pizza / 3 Petaluma Blvd N, Petaluma, CA 94952, United States /

Neighborhood New York–Style Pizzeria

The New Yorker Pizza serves classic New York–style pies with a notably crisp, well-baked crust, balanced sauce, and fresh mozzarella. This small, family-run spot offers a straightforward, unfussy setting suited to both dine-in and takeout. Guests also find familiar accompaniments like wings and salads, along with a modest selection of beer and wine.