The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in San Mateo, California

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse offers a spacious, bustling setting with a broad selection of house beers and hearty American favorites. Generous portions, from shareable starters to main dishes like chicken and sliders, cater to casual dining and groups. Prompt seating, comfortable booths, and attentive servers contribute to a relaxed, enjoyable experience.

Rainbow Pizza offers a broad menu of Greek and Italian dishes, from customizable pizzas with various crusts and toppings to classic entrées like veal or calamari piccata. Generous portions and hearty flavors often leave diners with leftovers. The setting can be lively and busy, while the staff provides welcoming, efficient service.

Mr Pizza Man San Mateo offers classic Italian-American comfort food, from pizzas with a well-seasoned crust to hearty pastas and sandwiches. Guests describe the small dining room as cozy and pleasant, with welcoming, attentive staff. Delivery orders arrive hot and well-prepared, and simple desserts like cheesecake are noted as a satisfying finish.

Amici's East Coast Pizzeria serves Boston-style pizza with a signature charred crust alongside a range of classic Italian dishes. Guests highlight the antipasto salad with its crisp lettuce, salami, mozzarella, and anchovy-rich dressing, as well as hearty options like meat lasagna. The setting suits both relaxed meals and takeout, with a broad menu that encourages repeat visits.

North Beach Pizza offers classic, generously topped pizzas with a flavorful crust, complemented by appetizers like calamari and simple salads. Guests describe a welcoming dining room with an authentic pizzeria feel and attentive, upbeat staff. Delivery orders arrive reliably, making it a convenient option for relaxed meals in or out.

Round Table Pizza serves classic American-style pies known for their consistent, flavorful crusts and generous toppings. Popular choices such as combination and gourmet garlic pizzas arrive hot and well prepared. The casual dining room includes space for group gatherings and celebrations, along with a small game area that adds to the family-friendly atmosphere.

New York Pizza serves classic New York–style pies with a balanced crust and generous toppings, available by the slice or as oversized party pizzas. Guests can also choose from a range of pastas, hot sandwiches, salads, and desserts. The restaurant offers a straightforward, casual setting suited to both quick meals and larger gatherings.

California Pizza Kitchen San Mateo offers a lively, contemporary setting for enjoying inventive pizzas alongside salads, hearty dishes, and desserts. Thin and cauliflower crust options feature bold, well-balanced flavors, and specialties like braised short ribs in mac and cheese stand out. The dining room is often bustling, with attentive service that remains engaged throughout the meal.

Seniore's Pizza is a local pizzeria known for its hearty, thick-crust pies and generous toppings. Guests highlight flavorful options like Italian sausage and appreciate the abundance of cheese and fresh ingredients. The kitchen is accommodating with toppings and crust choices, including a gluten-free option, and offers both whole pies and customizable slices. Friendly counter service and convenient takeout contribute to its appeal.