The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Aurora, Colorado

Mama Alvino's Pizzeria is a long-established spot known for hearty Italian-American comfort food, especially its generously filled calzones. Guests also appreciate the classic pizza, spaghetti plates, and salads that recall East Coast neighborhood eateries. The dining room is simple, clean, and generally quiet, and takeout service is consistently reliable.

Wood Paddle Pizza & Tap specializes in wood-fired pizza with a crisp crust, flavorful red sauce, and generous fresh toppings. Guests order at the counter and settle into a casual, welcoming space with attentive staff. The menu extends to salads and sandwiches, complemented by a rotating selection of craft beers and a thoughtful wine list.

Marco's Pizza is a welcoming neighborhood spot known for its flavorful sauce, well-balanced crust, and generously topped pies. Guests highlight both thin and pan-style pizzas, along with cheesy bread and hearty sandwiches on warm, crusty bread. The bar offers beer and house specialty shots, adding to the lively, casual atmosphere. Attentive staff and an engaged owner contribute to a personable dining experience.

Jet's Pizza specializes in hearty, customizable pizzas with options ranging from deep dish to thin and hand-tossed crusts. Guests can tailor their pizzas with various crust seasonings and classic topping combinations. While the compact dining area suits a quick sit-down meal, the shop also serves a steady stream of takeout orders, with staff generally attentive to correcting any issues.

Cicis Pizza offers a casual, family-oriented buffet focused on a variety of pizzas, a salad bar, and simple desserts. Guests appreciate the option to request custom pizzas and enjoy additional items like wings and hot soup. The atmosphere is lively, with arcade-style games appealing to children and teens, and the dining area is generally kept clean and orderly.