The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Idaho

Embers By The Lake offers wood-fired pizzas made with handmade dough and carefully chosen, gourmet-style toppings. Guests describe a cozy, welcoming setting that suits families, date nights, and casual drinks with friends, with space for children to play nearby. Prompt, patient service and a selection of salads and drinks round out the relaxed, social dining experience.

Old Ice House Pizzeria serves generously sized, thin-crust pizzas with a focus on flavorful toppings, from specialty combinations like Greek-style pies to hearty meat-focused options. Guests can easily customize any pizza, making it simple to tailor orders to different tastes. Warm, attentive staff and plentiful seating complement views of the nearby lake for a relaxed, casual outing.

New York Richie's offers creative pizzas, including Indian-inspired options like chicken curry pizza, alongside fresh salads and yogurt-based drinks such as mango lassi. Sauces and toppings are described as flavorful and well-prepared. The spacious interior, with pool tables and a large banquet room, pairs with attentive, friendly service for a relaxed dining experience.

Powder Hound Pizza serves fresh, hot pizzas with both classic and creative topping combinations, along with salads, ribs, and shareable sides. Guests appreciate the option to customize their pies and the consistently flavorful preparations. The compact dining room offers views down the mountain and a bustling, energetic atmosphere, supported by an active takeout service.

Pizza Stop is a casual neighborhood pizzeria known for its flavorful pies, from familiar favorites to veggie and gourmet combinations. The menu extends to comforting Italian-style dishes, including pasta, salads, wings, and desserts, with items like shrimp fettuccine Alfredo and a spinach strawberry-pecan salad. A clean dining area with both upstairs booths and additional downstairs seating accommodates everything from quick meals to larger gatherings.

Red Bench Pizza specializes in brick-oven pies with a chewy crust and fresh ingredients, offering both classic and creative topping combinations. The menu includes personal-sized pizzas, salads, and appetizers such as risotto balls and meatballs. Gluten-free and cauliflower crust options are available, along with a selection of beer and wine. Attentive, personable service and a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere define the experience.

Rock City Mercantile is a family-run stop near City of Rocks that combines a casual eatery with a well-stocked general store. Guests highlight its hearty pizzas with generous toppings, satisfying sandwiches, and broad beer selection. The atmosphere is informal and welcoming, making it a convenient place to relax and recharge after time outdoors.

The Wylder is a lively Boise restaurant focused on creative pizzas and shareable small plates. Guests highlight the crisp, flavorful pies with inventive topping combinations and the option to sample multiple styles on one pizza. Starters such as Italian meatballs, Brussels sprouts, and roasted cauliflower, along with generous salads, make it a popular choice for date nights and groups.

Bedroom Goldmine Bar offers a casual bar setting known for its flavorful pizza, cold drinks, and welcoming service. Guests enjoy pool, appetizers, and a lively crowd, while the walls display memorabilia celebrating Murray’s mining past. An original mine shaft and the building’s colorful history add a distinctive sense of place to the experience.

Clear Creek Station serves freshly made American comfort food, including hearty burgers and simple steak dishes, in a casual, roadside setting. Guests describe the dining area as comfortable and the staff as welcoming and attentive. A connected convenience store offers drinks and snacks, and there is a broad selection of beer available on tap and in bottles.

The Front Door Taphouse specializes in flavorful, medium-thin crust pizzas with inventive topping combinations, complemented by salads, wraps, and wings. A rotating selection of craft beers adds to the appeal. The cozy interior can become lively and loud, while attentive, efficient service and televised sports contribute to the energetic atmosphere.

Studebaker's Pizza is a modest, counter-service spot known for its hearty pizzas, subs, and cheesy bread. The generous portions and satisfying flavors appeal to both locals and travelers passing through town. A compact dining area and nostalgic décor give the place a down-to-earth, family-run feel. Lively chatter and the aroma of fresh-baked dough create a welcoming atmosphere.

Pizza Pie Cafe offers a casual buffet focused on pizza, pasta, and a self-serve salad bar, giving guests plenty of options to customize their meal. The atmosphere is lively and popular with groups and families. Staff members are described as welcoming and helpful, and the food is noted as fresh even during busy periods.

Idaho Pizza Company serves thin-crust pizzas with fresh, flavorful toppings alongside a well-stocked salad bar. Guests note attentive, courteous service that keeps the table well looked after. The spacious dining room offers a comfortable setting for enjoying classic pizza favorites and a relaxed meal.

Tatanka Tavern specializes in wood-fired pizzas served in a relaxed tavern setting. Located on an upper-floor rooftop with balcony seating, it offers appealing views over the town. Guests appreciate the crisp, well-fired crusts, a focused selection of pizzas, and a rotating list of wines and craft beers, along with attentive, personable service at both tables and the bar.