The Best Italian Restaurants in Sandpoint

Second Avenue Pizza is known for its generously sized pizzas and calzones, piled with fresh toppings and prepared in an open kitchen. Crisp garden salads and ample portions make it a popular choice for both locals and visitors. The counter-service setup runs efficiently, even during the evening rush, and the staff maintains a clean, welcoming dining space.

Arlo's Ristorante serves New York–style Italian cuisine with carefully prepared pastas, seafood, and classic sauces. Guests appreciate both indoor and outdoor seating, a comfortable bar for wine before dinner, and attentive, professional service. Family recipes and thoughtful flavor combinations create a satisfying, relaxed dining experience.

Babs' Pizzeria brings classic New York–style thin-crust pizza to Sandpoint, with slices and whole pies that are easy to fold yet sturdy under generous toppings. The menu also includes a selection of Italian-inspired dishes, such as pasta salads, plus a gluten-free crust option. A specialty balsamic-topped pizza stands out among the offerings, and the casual dine-in and takeout setup creates an easygoing neighborhood feel.