The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Springfield, Illinois

Bernie & Betty's Pizza is a longstanding Springfield favorite known for its thin-crust pies topped with fresh, finely cut ingredients. Guests mention classic combinations such as sausage, pepperoni, and mushrooms, along with appealing appetizers like fried baby portobellos and simple salads. The restaurant offers both dine-in and carryout, providing a straightforward, satisfying pizza experience for locals and visitors alike.

Joe's Italian Pizza in Springfield (not Lincoln) serves Italian‑American comfort food with a focus on pizza and pasta. Guests highlight the crisp, flaky crust, generous cheese and toppings, and a slightly sweet marinara sauce. Made-to-order pasta cooked al dente and a tangy house Italian dressing round out the menu, with desserts like brownies noted as an additional treat.

Chuck E. Cheese offers a lively, family-oriented setting combining classic arcade-style games with casual pizza dining. Guests note the clean facilities, working games, and convenient card-based play system. Staff members are described as attentive and helpful, especially during group visits. The venue is popular for hosting children’s celebrations in a bright, playful environment.

Papa Johns Pizza offers carryout and delivery-only service with timely orders that often arrive earlier than estimated. Guests enjoy classic, customizable pizzas accompanied by the signature garlic butter and pepper, along with familiar sides and desserts. Friendly, professional drivers and thoughtful touches like plates and napkins enhance the overall convenience.

Antonio's Pizza focuses on classic pizza with a reputation for generous toppings and consistently hot delivery. Guests note friendly staff and an owner who shows concern for employees. This is primarily a takeout and delivery spot with no indoor seating, suitable for casual meals brought home or to the workplace.

Godfather's Pizza offers a casual buffet featuring a wide selection of freshly made pizzas and classic comfort items like fried chicken and sides. Pies are replenished frequently, and staff accommodate special requests such as thicker crusts. Guests describe the dining room as clean and welcoming, with attentive, friendly service throughout the visit.

Luca Pizza serves classic New York–style thin-crust pies, including large-format options suited for groups. Guests mention consistently well-cooked pizzas alongside a menu of calzones, salads, pasta, and appetizers. The setting is casual and family-friendly, with helpful staff at the counter and delivery available for added convenience.

Antonio's Pizza is a local favorite known for its flavorful pies with generous toppings, well-balanced sauce, and satisfying crusts in both thick and thin styles. Pizzas and sides such as chicken wings and bites typically arrive hot and freshly made, whether for delivery or takeout. Consistent quality and hearty portions make it a reliable choice for classic pizzeria fare.