The Best Italian Restaurants in Wheeling, Illinois

Joe's Pizzeria is a long-standing local spot known for its thin crust pizza loaded with melted cheese and fresh ingredients. The atmosphere is simple and unpretentious, focusing squarely on hearty, satisfying pies. Attentive staff and consistently well-made pizzas have kept this pizzeria a community favorite for decades.

D'Agostino's Pizzeria Wheeling offers casual Italian-American pub fare, from pizzas and chicken parm to hearty appetizers and desserts. Guests highlight the flavorful garlic bread, loaded tater tots, and a decadent cookie ice cream sundae. Service is described as genuinely friendly and attentive. A simple dining room contrasts with a cozy bar area featuring a long bar and video gaming.