The Best Caribbean Restaurants in Indiana

Montego Bay Grille

3.48(0 reviews)

USD 12

Caribbean / 322 Main St, Hobart, IN 46342, United States /

Jamaican-Inspired Neighborhood Grill

Montego Bay Grille offers Jamaican-inspired cooking in an intimate, unpretentious setting. The Jamaican owner, who also serves as head chef, prepares dishes with a personal, home-style touch, from jerk chicken and Cajun-accented plates to hearty burgers. Guests note generous portions and enjoy specialties like fried plantains with caramel sauce, along with attentive, personable service that adds to the relaxed, welcoming feel.

Cool Runnings Food Truck

3.00(0 reviews)

Caribbean / 112 E 11th St, Michigan City, IN 46360-3638, United States /

Laid-Back Jamaican and Caribbean Flavors

Cool Runnings Food Truck serves authentic Jamaican and Caribbean-inspired dishes, with jerk chicken dinners, jerk catfish, and crab rolls frequently praised for their bold, spicy flavors. A casual setting with Caribbean music, decor, and open-air seating creates a relaxed island-style atmosphere, complemented by easygoing, personable service.

Jamaican Reggae Grill

3.00(0 reviews)

Caribbean / 622 S Rangeline Rd Monon Square, Carmel, IN 46032-2124, United States /

Casual Jamaican Jerk and Comfort Dishes

Jamaican Reggae Grill serves hearty Jamaican comfort food, with jerk chicken, brown stew chicken, and wings noted for bold, spicy flavors. Hot, freshly prepared plates often come with sides like fried plantains, and portions are described as generous. The setting suits a relaxed meal after the nearby trail, and the staff is described as polite and helpful.