The 20 Best Restaurants in Belmar

Sonny's Grille is a family-run spot serving cooked-to-order American comfort food, including burgers, wings, salads, subs, and all-day breakfast sandwiches. An extensive selection of signature hot dogs and house chili stands out on the menu. Large wooden picnic tables, sports memorabilia, and classic Hollywood photos create a relaxed, nostalgic setting. Attentive counter service and a lively atmosphere contribute to its welcoming feel.

Main Street Donuts offers a creative selection of donuts, including visually striking gluten-free options that receive enthusiastic praise for their flavor. The shop presents its treats and gift items with an artistic touch, creating an inviting, colorful display. Guests note the warm welcome and attentive service that add to the enjoyable start to the day.

Sweet! specializes in generously sized, moist cupcakes, many with rich fillings in flavors like chocolate caramel and peanut butter chocolate. The shop also offers homemade ice cream, chocolate-dipped treats, nostalgic candies, and even house-made dog snacks. Staff members are known for helpful guidance, from choosing flavors to arranging attractive cupcake displays for gatherings.

Federici's on 10th offers classic Italian-American cooking in a casual neighborhood setting, with both indoor seating and a covered outdoor area overlooking 10th Avenue. Guests highlight the thin-crust pizza, eggplant Parmesan with pasta, and chicken specialties for their satisfying flavor and portions. Attentive, efficient service and a relaxed, unhurried atmosphere characterize the dining experience at this BYO restaurant.

Turnstile Coffee Roasters is a neighborhood café specializing in house-roasted coffee from various regions, prepared with care by skilled baristas. Guests highlight the rich cappuccinos, custom pour-over options, and quality decaf cold brew. The space offers comfortable seating and a calm, inviting atmosphere for enjoying thoughtfully crafted coffee and light bites.

Comfi of Belmar is a cozy diner-style spot known for hearty breakfast and lunch favorites alongside a few standout Polish specialties. Guests highlight generously filled omelets, crisp breakfast potatoes, and notably rich potato-and-cheese pierogies. A homestyle chicken cutlet with mashed red potatoes and mushroom gravy reflects the kitchen’s comfort-food focus. Friendly, attentive service and a refreshed interior add to the welcoming feel.

Ragin Cajun serves hearty Cajun-inspired dishes, with guests praising flavorful staples like jambalaya and tender beef tips, as well as regional specialties such as alligator bites. The atmosphere is welcoming and energetic, supported by courteous, attentive staff. An outdoor patio along Route 35 offers marina views and colorful sunsets, creating a distinctive setting for a relaxed meal.

Federico's Pizza & Restaurant offers classic pizzeria favorites and Italian-American dishes in a casual, welcoming setting. Guests highlight crisp, generously topped pizzas, hearty salads such as the signature Federico salad, and comforting sides. Attentive, friendly service and efficient takeout make it a popular choice for both relaxed meals and quick pickups, with an outdoor patio available.

Beckman's Deli is a casual neighborhood spot known for hearty breakfast sandwiches, including pork roll or bacon with egg and cheese on fresh rolls. The compact kitchen turns out a broad deli-style menu with burgers, subs, chicken, and fried favorites. A few simple tables and a steady takeout trade give it an unfussy, everyday feel.

Anchor Tavern offers classic American comfort food, from hearty burgers and fried chicken to soups and sandwiches. Guests highlight the flavorful clam chowder, French onion soup, and house sangria. Attentive, courteous service and a laid-back tavern atmosphere create an easygoing dining experience, with an outdoor patio that adds to the appeal.

Mr Shrimp offers a broad selection of seafood dishes in a clean, spacious setting that feels more restaurant than fish market. Guests highlight well-seasoned fried platters, fish and chips, steamers, and classic shrimp cocktails, along with pasta and surf-and-turf options. Attentive service and a comfortable dining room contribute to an enjoyable, low-key experience.

Kaya's Kitchen offers a fully vegan menu with hearty comfort food, including satisfying burgers and flavorful sides. Guests appreciate the fresh, vegetable-forward preparations, such as the popular potato salad. House-made desserts, like rich brownies and layered cakes, are frequently highlighted. Attentive staff and a laid-back, BYOB setting create an inviting place for plant-based dining.

Coney Waffle specializes in inventive ice cream and waffle desserts, including house-made waffles folded around multiple scoops and toppings. Cones are often elaborately decorated, with options like cotton candy and assorted candies creating a visually striking treat. Portions are generous enough for sharing, appealing to both children and adults. Attentive, easygoing staff contribute to a lighthearted, beachside treat experience.