The 20 Best Irish Restaurants in New Jersey

Killarney's Publick House is a bustling pub known for its well-poured Guinness on tap, hearty American comfort food, and southwest-inspired options. Diners mention a wide range of appetizers, sandwiches, and classic entrées, complemented by seasonal drinks like pumpkin beer with a sugared rim. An outdoor patio with frequent live music creates an energetic, social atmosphere that suits casual gatherings and happy hour meetups.

Thatcher McGhee's Denville is a cozy Irish pub and restaurant offering authentic Irish favorites alongside classic pub fare. A full bar with many beers on tap and multiple TVs creates an energetic, sports-bar feel. Guests highlight well-prepared dishes, from hearty Irish breakfasts to fish and chips, along with attentive, efficient service.

Danaher’s Pub offers a mix of Irish and American pub favorites, from hearty classics like shepherd’s pie to popular comfort dishes such as French onion soup. A full bar with a broad selection of drinks and rotating specials anchors the experience. The atmosphere is energetic and social, with attentive, welcoming service that suits both casual meals and watching the game.

Hailey's Harp & Pub offers a classic Irish pub experience with hearty comfort food and a broad draft beer selection. Guests highlight dishes such as prime rib, burgers, French onion soup, and bar pies served hot with well-balanced flavors. Live music and a welcoming staff contribute to an energetic yet comfortable atmosphere suitable for both casual lunches and group gatherings.

P.J. Finnegan's is a bustling Irish pub known for generous drinks and consistently satisfying pub fare. Guests highlight hearty appetizers, classic fish and chips, sliced steak, and sandwiches. Attentive, upbeat service and a crowd of regulars create a lively bar atmosphere, with outdoor seating adding to the appeal when the weather is pleasant.

Brady’s Fox Hunt Inn serves hearty Irish and European-inspired comfort food in a welcoming, inn-style setting. Guests note classics such as bangers and mash, shepherd’s pie, stews, and sauerbraten, alongside seafood, pasta, and daily soups. Fresh scones and popular appetizers like fried calamari open the meal, and attentive, personable service contributes to the inviting atmosphere.

Josie Kelly's Public House combines classic Irish pub favorites with more elevated, globally inspired dishes. Guests highlight well-prepared staples such as fish and chips and beef and Guinness pie alongside creative options like lobster tostadas. The atmosphere ranges from a lively bar scene to a private upstairs whiskey room suited for gatherings, with attentive service and a clean, well-kept space.

Celtic Corner Restaurant and Pub offers hearty Irish-inspired pub fare, with guests often praising the crisp, generous fish and chips and flavorful appetizers. Desserts such as bread pudding and ice cream cake add a comforting finish to the meal. The setting is laid-back, and attentive staff and management frequently check in, creating an engaging, easygoing dining experience.

St James's Gate Publick House offers a traditional Irish pub setting with wood-accented decor and a relaxed, neighborhood feel. The kitchen focuses on hearty pub favorites, from burgers with chips to dishes like Gaelic steak with whiskey mushroom sauce. Well-kept draft beers, straightforward cocktails, and attentive bar service complete the experience.

Mac's Pub offers a mix of American and Irish pub classics in a lively bar setting with plenty of TVs and seating. Guests highlight flavorful burgers, hearty sandwiches, mussels in garlic sauce, and pizza. The space is kept clean, and the attentive staff provides efficient, accommodating service.

Irish Pub and Irish Pub Inn offers a nostalgic tavern experience, with dim lighting, antique decor, and touches of local history, including baseball memorabilia. The kitchen focuses on straightforward pub favorites such as fish and chips, crabcakes, and hearty sandwiches, noted as flavorful and satisfying. Attentive bartenders and servers contribute to an easygoing, old-fashioned pub atmosphere.

Dublin House occupies a large converted historic house, offering a bustling bar, comfortable dining rooms, and an attractive brick patio for outdoor seating. The menu features satisfying pub-style dishes, from burgers and sandwiches to seafood and salads. Attentive, efficient service and a consistently energetic atmosphere define the experience.