The 20 Best Sandwich Restaurants in New Jersey

Don's Sandwich Shop

4.30(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 606 Main St, Boonton, NJ 07005, United States /

Classic Neighborhood Sandwich Shop

Don's Sandwich Shop specializes in generously filled subs and sandwiches made on soft, fresh rolls, from pastrami Reubens to Italian and roast beef favorites. Breakfast options like bacon, egg, and cheese are prepared to order with attention to detail. The small, tidy shop has a nostalgic feel, with friendly, attentive staff who accommodate individual preferences. Sandwich platters are neatly prepared with thoughtful touches for groups and gatherings.

B J Sandwich Shop

4.58(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 329 US-46, Budd Lake, NJ 07828, United States /

American Melts

4.15(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 515 Springfield Rd, Kenilworth, NJ 07033, United States /

Creative Grilled Cheese and Melt Sandwiches

American Melts specializes in creative grilled cheese and melt sandwiches, offering both signature combinations and build-your-own options. Diners highlight the variety of breads, cheeses, and fillings, from classic blends to inventive choices like grilled mac and cheese or a grilled cheese hot dog. The casual, outdoor picnic-table seating adds to its laid-back, roadside stand feel.

Neil's Kitchen

4.05(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 126 West End Ct, Long Branch, NJ 07740, United States /

Creative Handcrafted Sandwiches

Neil's Kitchen is a neighborhood sandwich shop known for its creative combinations and generous portions. Fresh ingredients and made-to-order preparation give each sandwich a distinct character, from hearty chicken and pork options to popular vegetable choices like eggplant. Daily specials and a catering service add to the appeal for both quick bites and casual meals.

Our Hero

4.26(0 reviews)

USD 6

Sandwich / 785 Bergen Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07306-4506, United States /

Nick's Sandwich Shop

4.04(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 505 Saddle River Rd, Saddle Brook, NJ 07663, United States /

Lee's Hoagie House

4.01(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 9832 3rd Ave, Stone Harbor, NJ 08247, United States /

The Great Wazu

3.88(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 3036 US-46, Parsippany-Troy Hills, NJ 07054, United States /

Old-School Sandwich Shop with Generous Subs

The Great Wazu is an old-school sandwich shop known for its substantial subs made with thinly sliced meats and distinctive bread. Roast beef and tuna sandwiches are frequently mentioned as highlights. The long, narrow interior features simple table seating and a large overhead menu board. Lively, sometimes brusque counter service and quick-moving lunch lines give it a classic deli-style feel.

Big Wally's Subs

3.84(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 3322 Washington Rd, Parlin, NJ 08859, United States /

Hearty Local Sub Shop

Big Wally’s Subs is a local sandwich spot known for its generously sized hot and cold subs made with fresh ingredients. The kitchen operates efficiently, turning out well-stuffed heroes with consistent flavor and balance. Prompt, courteous service, including for phone orders and pickups, adds to the straightforward, satisfying experience focused squarely on the subs.

Cafe Airlie

3.84(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 32 Commerce St, Newark, NJ 07102-4003, United States /

Bustling Sandwich Café in Newark

Cafe Airlie is a compact, lively café known for its generous hot and cold sandwiches with classic, creatively named combinations. Fresh, made-to-order salads, soups, and a wide selection of chips and drinks round out the menu. The counter-style setup keeps service moving even during the busy lunch rush, making it a popular stop for flavorful, deli-style fare.

Classic Sub Shop

3.80(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 1164 NJ-33, Hamilton Square, NJ 08690, United States /

Traditional Deli-Style Subs

Classic Sub Shop serves traditional deli-style subs made with meats and cheeses sliced to order and served on fresh, well-regarded bread. Generous fillings and crisp lettuce and tomato create satisfying, straightforward sandwiches. The staff is noted for being courteous and efficient, and the compact dining area provides a simple, no-frills place to enjoy a quick meal.

Sub Pub

3.57(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 127 Main St, Chester, NJ 07930, United States /

Classic Sub Sandwich Spot in Chester

Sub Pub is a longtime Chester staple known for its generous, deli-style sub sandwiches made with fresh ingredients. Guests choose from a range of hot and cold options, including combinations named after local towns, all served on distinctive crispy rolls with various toppings. Simple indoor seating and a porch area offer a casual place to enjoy a satisfying sub on Main Street.

Sub Shack & Deli

3.71(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 312 Main St, Hackettstown, NJ 07840, United States /

Hearty Subs and Classic Deli Fare

Sub Shack and Deli is a longtime Hackettstown staple known for generously filled subs made to order. Guests choose from a wide variety of sandwich combinations, with options for half or whole portions that are notably substantial. The shack also offers classic deli sides such as pickles, deviled eggs, and homemade salads, along with a selection of beverages. Limited counter space makes it a popular spot for takeout.

Vic's Subs

3.51(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 742 Ohio Ave, Absecon, NJ 08201, United States /

Hearty Local Sub Shop

Vic's Subs is a long-standing neighborhood spot known for its generously filled subs and cheesesteaks. Guests highlight satisfying options like pepper steak and meatball sandwiches, along with crisp fries. The shop often draws a busy crowd, reflecting its strong local following and casual, welcoming atmosphere.

Sandwiches Unlimited Lunch Box

3.98(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 350 US-46 #116, Rockaway, NJ 07866, United States /

Skyler's Hoagies

3.78(0 reviews)

USD 8

Sandwich / 1200 S Church St, Mt Laurel Township, NJ 08054, United States /

Russo's Market

3.62(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 901 Ocean Ave, North Wildwood, NJ 08260, United States /

Bustling Deli and Neighborhood Market

Russo's Market is a long-established neighborhood shop known for its busy deli counter and hearty hot sandwiches. The market stocks a wide range of snacks, beverages, and everyday essentials, convenient for visitors and locals alike. Fresh breakfast sandwiches, donuts, and soft pretzels are popular in the morning, while cheesesteaks draw crowds throughout the day. Service is organized and efficient, even when the space is bustling.

Just Subs

3.61(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 422 US-206, Hillsborough Township, NJ 08844, United States /

Classic Neighborhood Sub Shop

Just Subs is a straightforward sandwich shop specializing in hearty hot and cold subs on fresh, flavorful bread. Guests highlight the generous portions, from roast beef to chicken salad, and consistently satisfying taste. The atmosphere is unfussy and busy, with an efficient counter team keeping lines moving. A reliable spot for traditional, made-to-order subs.

Frenchtown Fresh

3.90(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 2 Race St, Frenchtown, NJ 08825, United States /

Sorrento's Subs

3.56(0 reviews)

USD 15

Sandwich / 690 Park Ave, Freehold, NJ 07728, United States /

Hearty Subs and Classic Breakfast Sandwiches

Sorrento's Subs is known for generously filled subs and classic breakfast sandwiches made on fresh bread and rolls. Guests can watch their sandwiches assembled behind a glass counter, adding to the lively, bustling feel. The atmosphere is casual and cafeteria-style, often busy during peak hours. It is a convenient spot for satisfying comfort food throughout the day.

Reservation Method

Distance

Price Range

Ratings

Seating Options

Hours

Smoking

Awards

Michelin Guide

Occasion

Facilities

Reservation Method

Distance

Price Range

Ratings

Seating Options

Hours

Smoking

Awards

Michelin Guide

Occasion

Facilities

Popular areas in New Jersey

Trending Cuisines in New Jersey

The 20 Best Sandwich Restaurants in New Jersey

Jersey City

Newark

Atlantic City

Hoboken

Toms River

Paterson

Elizabeth

Edison

Trenton

Woodbridge Township

Italian

American

Pizza

Bar

Chinese

Pub

Japanese

Mexican

Seafood

Cafe

The Best Restaurants in California - Sandwich

The Best Restaurants in Texas - Sandwich