The Best Pizza Restaurants in Toms River

Al's Pizza serves classic Jersey shore–style pies with a crisp, thin crust, alongside Sicilian slices and other casual Italian favorites. Guests mention well-prepared options such as eggplant Parmesan, Italian hot dogs, and salads. The dining room can be lively at lunchtime, and the staff is noted for being accommodating and helpful.

Attilio's Pizza is a casual neighborhood spot known for its well-cooked pies with fresh, high-quality toppings and crisp crusts. The menu includes a dedicated selection of gluten-free options, including pizza and appetizers, prepared with attention to flavor and texture. Guests also note satisfying salads, sandwiches, and desserts, as well as reliable delivery for larger orders.

Schiano's Pizza Toms River is a modest, casual spot specializing in classic Italian-American dishes and pizza. Guests highlight the Neapolitan-style pies with a crisp yet tender crust and flavorful sauce, along with comforting pasta favorites like baked ziti and lasagna. Fresh salads and simple, attentive service contribute to the welcoming, neighborhood feel of the dining room. A steady stream of takeout and dine-in guests reflects its standing as a reliable local choice.

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza serves classic Italian favorites, from brick-oven pies and lasagna to chicken francaise and generous appetizers. Guests highlight the flavorful sauces and well-prepared dishes, including popular garlic knots and calamari. The atmosphere is welcoming, with attentive staff and an engaging Sicilian owner. The comfortable dining room accommodates both small parties and larger groups.

Capone's Gourmet Pizza & Pasta offers classic Italian dishes alongside gourmet pizzas, with generous portions and thoughtfully prepared pastas, chicken, and eggplant specialties. Housemade starters like garlic knots and gnocchi set the tone for a satisfying meal. Attentive, professional service and small touches such as complimentary olives, bread, and careful packing of leftovers create a comfortable, welcoming dining experience.

Pizza & Panini offers casual Italian fare in a small, unpretentious space with picnic-style seating and simple decor. Freshly prepared pizzas, flavorful panini sandwiches, and pasta sides are highlighted for their inviting presentation and taste. Attentive, personable service and a welcoming atmosphere make it a favored spot for both quick lunches and relaxed dinners.

Enzo’s offers classic Italian-American cuisine in spacious dining rooms with a comfortable, welcoming feel. Guests highlight flavorful preparations such as chicken specialties, seafood, and pasta, complemented by fresh salads and warm rolls with herbed oil. The BYOB policy lets diners pair their own wines with the meal, and the staff is known for accommodating special requests, including options for younger diners.