The Best Pizza Restaurants in Wayne, New Jersey

Anthony Franco's Pizza - Wayne is a spacious neighborhood spot known for its wide selection of pizzas and hearty Italian-American dishes. Guests mention satisfying thick-crust slices alongside chicken specialties, pastas, and fresh salads. The atmosphere is casual and family-oriented, with many young diners and a lively noise level. Service is described as friendly and efficient for both dine-in and takeout orders.

Pizza One is a compact neighborhood pizzeria known for hot, fresh pies and a wide variety of slices. Guests highlight both the classic plain pie and more adventurous combinations, complemented by a flavorful house sauce. Orders are prepared with care, and the staff responds promptly if anything needs adjustment, contributing to a consistently reliable experience.

Brother Bruno's Pizza, Deli & Bagels is known for its substantial deep-dish and stuffed pizzas, with slices that many find very filling. Guests highlight creative options such as penne alla vodka pizza and indulgent dessert pies. Generous portions and consistently attentive service contribute to a satisfying, casual dining experience.

Time Out Cafe offers hearty deli-style sandwiches, oversized pizza, wings, and footlong hot dogs made with fresh ingredients. Generous portions and Boar’s Head meats are a highlight, especially in the subs. A playful sports theme, with team tables and multiple TVs, creates an easygoing, game-day atmosphere. Attentive, accommodating staff add to the laid-back neighborhood feel.