The Best American Restaurants in Long Beach, New York

Lost And Found is an intimate spot offering seasonal, eclectic small plates with a Mediterranean influence, from vibrant salads to roasted vegetables and house hummus. Dishes are prepared with evident care and presented artistically, complemented by a thoughtfully curated global wine selection and beer. The knowledgeable, attentive staff and cozy scale create an inviting setting for sharing plates, while the adjoining market showcases quality prepared foods, fresh produce, and pantry items.

JJ Coopers is a casual gastropub offering hearty portions of crowd-pleasing comfort food, including well-regarded seafood appetizers like tuna and calamari. A busy bar with an extensive beer selection creates an energetic atmosphere that can get quite loud at peak times. Service remains attentive even when the dining room is full, and seating is spacious enough for larger groups.

Speakeasy offers casual American bar fare with an emphasis on hearty comfort dishes like short rib grilled cheese, mac and cheese, and various fries. Guests describe the dining room as cozy and the overall space as spacious and welcoming. Friendly staff and attentive bartenders contribute to an easygoing atmosphere, with games on TV adding to the neighborhood bar feel.

Allegria Hotel Restaurant offers a varied menu complemented by custom cocktails, including popular margarita variations. Guests appreciate the flavorful dishes and the opportunity to dine at the bar or in the main restaurant. Floor-to-ceiling ocean views create a striking backdrop, adding to the relaxed, beachside atmosphere. Attentive staff contribute to a smooth and enjoyable dining experience.

Long Beach Hotel Bar Grill offers classic bar-and-grill fare, with guests praising the burgers, fries, tacos, crab cakes, and house-made desserts. A popular Sunday brunch and live music contribute to a lively, laid-back atmosphere, especially in warmer months. Service is generally friendly, though the dining room can feel busy during large events.