The Best American Restaurants in McFarland, Wisconsin

Luke's Cafe

3.71(0 reviews)

USD 15

American / 6115 US Hwy. 51, McFarland, WI 53558, United States /

Casual Neighborhood Cafe and Breakfast Spot

Luke's Cafe is a casual neighborhood spot in McFarland known for hearty American breakfast and comfort food. Guests appreciate the extensive menu, from pancakes and breakfast burritos to crisp home fries and freshly brewed coffee. Comfortable booths and views of the nearby park create an inviting setting. Attentive, friendly service and a welcoming tone make it a popular gathering place for locals and visitors alike.

Green Lantern Restaurant

3.62(0 reviews)

USD 15

American / 4412 Siggelkow Rd, McFarland, WI 53558-9448, United States /

Casual Wisconsin Supper Club and Bar

Green Lantern Restaurant offers a classic Wisconsin supper club experience with a large menu spanning breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Guests highlight hearty plates such as walleye with eggs, omelets, and notably crisp hash browns. The setting combines a lively bar, complete with pool tables and cocktails, with attentive table service. It provides a laid-back neighborhood atmosphere suited to both brunch and evening visits.

Maple Tree Supper Club

3.58(0 reviews)

USD 25

American / 6010 US Hwy 51, McFarland, WI 53558, United States /

Classic Wisconsin-Style Supper Club

Maple Tree Supper Club offers a traditional supper club experience with generous portions of prime rib, steaks, ribs, and classic fish fry. Guests highlight the well-stocked soup and salad bar and house cocktails, including a notably robust old fashioned. The atmosphere is lively, and service is described as prompt, attentive, and upbeat.