The 20 Best Italian Restaurants in St. Catharines

Mele Trattoria offers classic Italian cooking in a converted Victorian house with a warm dining room and an intimate back patio. Guests highlight the carefully prepared antipasti, including salumi and seafood selections, as well as flavorful pasta dishes such as rabbit ragu and seafood lasagna. Attentive, helpful service and thoughtful touches on the plate create a relaxed, welcoming experience.

The Tangerine Tortoise is a small, casual neighborhood restaurant with an unassuming storefront that still carries its original appliance shop sign. Inside, an owner-chef prepares a frequently changing menu, with guests praising the thin-crust pizzas, pâtés, and sliders. Carefully sourced ingredients and personal, attentive service create a relaxed setting for a laid-back meal with thoughtfully prepared food.

Coppola's Ristorante & Banquet Facility offers traditional Italian cooking, from pasta dishes to custom preparations such as mushroom risotto or vegetable primavera. The kitchen is accommodating with special requests and takeout orders are handled smoothly. A dedicated banquet area and attentive staff create a dependable setting for private events and celebrations.

Fresco's Euro Grille offers Italian-inspired cuisine in a comfortable, family-friendly setting, with options ranging from pastas and pizzas to burgers and seafood. Dishes are noted for fresh flavors and attractive plating, with items like butternut squash ravioli standing out. Multiple dining areas, including a bar and space suited to larger groups, create a versatile environment for both everyday meals and special occasions.

The Twisted Pig | Italian Kitchen offers classic Italian comfort dishes, with guests highlighting freshly made gnocchi, pasta, and aromatic wood-fired pizzas. Overlooking the harbor in Port Dalhousie, it provides scenic views from its dining room, patio, and rooftop deck. Attentive, personable service and a relaxed, inviting ambiance round out the experience.

Lina Linguini's Pasta & Grille offers comforting Italian classics such as spaghetti with meatballs and veal parmigiana, often paired with fresh Caesar or house salads with a distinctive dressing. The kitchen accommodates various dietary needs with gluten-free choices and vegetable substitutions for pasta. Plates are attractively presented, and the bustling dining room is supported by attentive, helpful service. A broad selection of drinks complements the meal.

Rollin' Pizza - Handcrafted Pizza + Pasta is a cozy spot known for its flavorful handcrafted pizzas with a well-regarded crust and inventive topping combinations. A large menu board highlights numerous choices, including build-your-own options, pastas, wings, salads, subs, and appetizers. The restaurant offers vegan and gluten-free selections, and guests note the clean space and personable service.

Johnny Rocco's Italian Grill offers classic Italian-style dishes alongside salads, wraps, and hearty specialties in a welcoming setting suited to both everyday meals and special gatherings. Guests highlight consistently enjoyable flavors and a good variety of drinks, including martinis. Attentive, personable service and the ability to handle larger groups contribute to its broad appeal.

oddBar. specializes in inventive pizzas, from classic pepperoni and cheese to more adventurous specialty styles, including Detroit-inspired options with a notably flavorful crust. Fresh toppings and carefully prepared dough are central to the experience. A spacious, open layout, distinctive cocktails, and attentive staff create a lively, contemporary atmosphere.

Boston Pizza offers a relaxed, family-friendly setting for classic North American comfort food, including pizzas, burgers, pasta dishes, and hearty desserts. Generous portions and customizable options cater to different tastes. Guests highlight attentive, accommodating service and the option to enjoy a quieter meal away from the main Niagara Falls crowds, with patio seating available.

Industria Pizzeria + Bar offers Italian-inspired dining centered on stone-oven pizzas and housemade pasta. Guests mention consistently flavorful dishes, from well-prepared pizzas to satisfying starters. Friendly, efficient service and contemporary decor, along with a spacious patio, create a comfortable setting for relaxed meals or a pre-movie stop.

Fabio's Pizza serves handcrafted pizzas known for their well-made crust, from regular to thinner, crisp styles. Diners highlight the fresh toppings, from vibrant vegetables to classic Italian ingredients, and a sauce with a distinctive, satisfying bite. Friendly, attentive staff contribute to an inviting experience for both dine-in and take-out orders.

Big Marco's Italian Restaurant serves comforting Italian favorites, with pizza as a standout, including specialty options such as the San Marino. A weekly buffet features a salad bar, made-to-order pasta, and a hot bar with items like roast chicken, meatballs, and pizza bread. Guests note welcoming, personable service for both dine-in and takeout.

Pie Guys Pizzeria serves classic pizzas with plentiful toppings, along with wings and hearty subs. The kitchen is accommodating with custom orders, including special requests for dietary needs. Staff remain attentive and helpful even when the shop is busy with takeout and delivery customers. The casual dining room attracts families and groups from the surrounding area.