The Best Pizza Restaurants in Hagerman, Idaho

Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs serves hearty pizzas and toasted subs on soft, bakery-style bread. Made-to-order sandwiches and pies feature generous fillings and toppings, with options like Italian subs, cheesesteaks, wings, salads, and cheesy breadsticks. The spacious dining room is clean and straightforward, and the young staff is generally polite and helpful.