The 20 Best Restaurants in Millburn

Basilico offers classic Italian cuisine with fresh pastas, seafood specials, and thoughtfully prepared antipasti. Guests highlight attentive, efficient service and an inviting dining room where open windows and outdoor seating create an airy feel. The restaurant serves Italian wine and allows BYOB, with espresso and generous desserts to finish the meal. Even when busy, the space remains comfortable for conversation.

Common Lot offers contemporary New American cuisine with a frequently changing, seasonal menu and artful presentation. Dishes such as wagyu short ribs, seafood, and carefully prepared vegetables highlight thoughtful flavors and textures. A casual, inviting setting with views of the open kitchen and an upstairs dining area complements attentive, personable service.

Located in The Mall at Short Hills, Legal Sea Foods - Short Hills focuses on New England–style seafood, from crab cakes and calamari to oysters and Maine lobster. Diners highlight well-prepared, flavorful dishes, including a popular tuna burger and warm rolls. The recently renovated space offers a polished environment, complemented by attentive, helpful service.

La Pergola offers an upscale Italian dining experience featuring classic dishes, seasonal specials, and generous portions. Guests highlight the quality of preparations, from veal and pork chops to fresh seafood and pasta. A tranquil outdoor area and polished, attentive service create a comfortable setting for both everyday meals and special occasions.

MoonShine Modern Supper Club offers contemporary American-style dishes, from brunch plates to steaks and shared hors d’oeuvres. Guests highlight flavorful, generously portioned food and well-made desserts. An upstairs loft with patio provides a stylish setting for private events, supported by organized planning and attentive service.

Set in the Short Hills train station, Boxcar Bar combines a cozy bar atmosphere with a full kitchen and frequent live music. The menu offers an eclectic mix of bar favorites, from tacos and wings to pizzas and shareable appetizers. Cocktails are a highlight, with skilled bartenders mixing well-crafted drinks. Friendly, attentive service and a welcoming vibe make it a comfortable spot for casual dining and drinks.

Saigon Cafe Millburn serves classic Vietnamese cuisine in a small, bright dining room with a few indoor tables, counter seats, and seasonal outdoor options. Guests highlight the fresh, clean flavors of pho, vermicelli bowls, banh mi, and summer rolls. Service is described as friendly, attentive, and well organized for both dine-in and pickup.

Mia Famiglia is a classic Italian deli offering hearty sandwiches made with fresh bread, quality cold cuts, and house-made sausage. The counter also features hot prepared foods, sauces, salads, and desserts to take home. Shelves are stocked with imported Italian specialties, creating a welcoming spot for provisions and takeaway meals.

Gian Marco Trattoria serves classic Italian favorites, from crisp pizza and hearty pastas to seafood and veal dishes, noted for fresh, flavorful preparations. The quiet dining room features cloth tablecloths, subdued lighting, and a comfortable, understated elegance. Attentive, accommodating service and the ability to host larger groups make it a popular choice for both everyday meals and special gatherings.

Par 440 Restaurant & Lounge offers club-style American dining on a public golf course, with hearty dishes like burgers, ribs, and pasta. Guests highlight well-prepared meals, from appetizers to desserts, along with generous drinks. The restaurant features both indoor seating and tented outdoor dining, sometimes accompanied by live music. Its relaxed, polished setting suits everything from a quick post-round bite to larger celebrations.

EVOO & LEMON offers a Mediterranean-inspired menu with contemporary touches, featuring dishes such as salmon, shared spreads with grilled bread, and creative seafood starters. Guests appreciate the flavorful preparations, generous portions, and the option to bring their own beverages. A calm, unhurried atmosphere and considerate service make it well suited to lingering over shared plates.

La Strada serves classic Italian cuisine with generous portions of pasta, seafood, and traditional meat dishes. Guests highlight tender gnocchi, flavorful cavatelli, and moist grilled salmon, along with well-prepared chicken and veal specialties. The atmosphere is welcoming, with attentive, accommodating service. A separate front area offers a casual setting for pizza.

Nordstrom Ebar Artisan Coffee is a casual café inside the mall offering artisan coffee drinks and a selection of teas with various milk options. Guests order at the counter and then relax while staff bring freshly prepared items to the table. Light fare such as salads, soups, and sandwiches, including favorites like tomato soup and a shrimp and arugula salad, makes it a comfortable stop during a day of shopping.

Millburn Delicatessen is a bustling neighborhood spot known for its generous sandwiches, salads, pastas, and sweet treats. Guests highlight the fresh rolls, flavorful cutlets, and inventive combinations like buffalo chicken or pesto chicken on focaccia. Breakfast sandwiches add to the appeal, and the service is described as friendly and efficient. Indoor and outdoor seating contribute to its casual, lively feel.

Liv Breads is an artisanal bakery and café known for its flaky croissants, rich chocolate babka, and European-style pastries. Guests enjoy robust, Italian-influenced espresso alongside a broad selection of baked goods. Fresh loaves, including traditional challah, make it a popular stop for taking bread home as well as for a relaxed coffee break.

The Cheesecake Factory offers a broad, multicultural menu with well-prepared dishes such as Chinese chicken salad. Its bakery counter showcases rich, indulgent cheesecakes, including flavors like lemon raspberry cream, chocolate varieties, and a layered pineapple upside-down style. Attentive service and consistent execution contribute to a dependable dining experience.